In 1987, the last time I followed college basketball, I cheered for the Hoosiers.
“Smart on the buzzer” will echo forever in my mind.
That was Keith Smart and the go-ahead bucket – on the buzzer – that added a third national championship to the resume of Bobby Knight.
Bobby Knight. That’s a basketball coach.
And in that NC-two-A championship game, the losers were the Orangemen. As those of us in Indiana cheered – I was a soldier there then – it was Syracuse who walked away, dazed in defeat.
That was the last time I followed college basketball.
And though I now work in Syracuse, and Syracuse is having a record-setting season, I am an admirer of the program, but not yet a fan. That will come with time.
So I write with objectivity, not fondness.
And objectivity makes me think that these recent accusations about alleged goings on in the Syracuse University men’s basketball program are bunk.
They strike me as nothing other than salacious fiction thrown like gasoline on the media fire in order to embarrass Syracuse and push it into a big cash settlement.
Let’s review.
Former assistant coach Bernie Fine is accused of molesting two ball boys, half-brothers, now grown to adulthood. When first he heard the allegations, and after being told that the university, the local paper and ESPN had looked into them a decade before, Coach Jim Boeheim said they were bogus and that they had been brought by money grubbers.
In short, he defended his friend of more than 40 years.
Then an audio tape came out. Yes, the police, the paper and ESPN had had it for 10 years, but the rest of us – including Jim Boeheim – hadn’t heard it.
But when we did, it turned our stomach.
Because it seemed, on the recording, that Bernie Fine’s wife was at least indirectly confirming the accusation of sexual abuse against her husband.
Boeheim did an about face.
And the university fired Fine.
And Boeheim got sued, by the supposed victims, for defamation. They claimed he had slandered them.
Interestingly, they didn’t hire a litigator. They hired a bomb thrower. Instead of an attorney accustomed to defamation trials, they hired an attorney accustomed to press conferences.
Get ready to groan in unison.
Gloria Allred.
A woman who, as far as I’m concerned, has never stood beside anyone who was telling the truth. In her long career, the people she’s represented seem largely to be losers looking for a payoff and a media circus.
Like this case.
I don’t question the claim that at least one of these young men was abused by Bernie Fine. That sickening claim has grown disgustingly plausible.
But this defamation suit has sadly grown disgustingly predictable. It is a money grab, beginning to end.
And the material filed as paperwork in the case this week is an example of that. In the filings, the plaintiff claims that Bernie Fine’s wife had sex of one type or another with several Syracuse basketball players over a number of years.
Further, he claims to have overheard a conversation in which Bernie Fine’s wife and the wife of an unnamed Syracuse basketball coach compared notes on and anatomical aspects of the various basketball players they had bedded.
The plaintiff said that he told Bernie Fine his wife was sleeping with players and that Fine did not respond. The Gloria Allred paperwork then reasons that if he didn’t respond, that means he wasn’t surprised. And if he wasn’t surprised, that meant he knew. And if he knew, Jim Boeheim knew. And if Jim Boeheim knew, then he knew that the men were telling the truth when they claimed to have been molested by Bernie Fine.
That is her logic chain.
It leaves a lot to be desired. Seldom have so many unlikely hypotheticals been strung together.
But here’s my question: What does that have to do with the defamation lawsuit?
How does calling one guy’s wife a slut prove that a different guy slandered you? And if the story is true and if Jim Boeheim knew, how would the fact that his friend’s wife was a cheater have led him to believe that his friend was a molester?
It just doesn’t make sense.
No, this accusation doesn’t have anything to do with the defamation case. It has to do with the shakedown.
Those uncorroborated and unlikely accusations don’t help the court case, but they do embarrass Syracuse. They put tremendous pressure on it. They are an attack upon its integrity and reputation which it can neither refute nor defend itself against.
Completely without substantiation, a certain number of people will go forward thinking that the Syracuse men’s basketball program was a Sodom and Gomorrah operation where players were passed around like party favors by middle-aged women.
That damages the reputation of the university and its basketball program – which is a cash cow for university academic operations.
And that damage isn’t an accident. It is a shot across the bow. It is a near kin of extortion.
And it is meant to bring Syracuse and its checkbook to the table. This is about the settlement. Not to hide the university’s culpability, but to save the university’s reputation.
Because it can’t win this case. Not where it counts. A judge can find neither Boeheim nor the university at fault, and still Syracuse could be dealt a crippling blow.
A blow that would affect every aspect of the university’s operation.
The situation is obvious: The university writes a check to make this all go away, or it sits in worried anticipation of the next filing.
This is this week’s allegation, and it will be chewed and rechewed across the country.
And the university will wait in terror for next week’s allegation. You don’t have to be a math major to know that this is a no-win situation. We are a society of guilty until proven innocent, and nobody knows that better than the people charged with protecting Syracuse University’s “brand.”
Syracuse is a good school. Jim Boeheim is a good man. For decades, the two of them have been a good pair. A tall kid from down the Thruway and the school he has funded and represented most of his adult life.
This is about wrecking that image, about destroying the reputation of all those years.
All in the name of money.
We don’t tolerate child molesting. But we don’t tolerate character assassination either.
And these charges are that.
They seek to assassinate the character of Syracuse University and its basketball team.














